12 Best Block Island Bars 2025

Block Island is an island of the Outer Lands coastal archipelago. It is located south of mainland Rhode Island. It is a popular summer tourist destination.

The main appeal of the area is its beautiful beaches and also its historic lighthouses. The light houses are Block Island North light on the Northern Tip of the island and Block Island Southeast Light on the south eastern coast.

The island is also very popular for its July 4th celebrations including the annual Fourth of July parade and the fireworks.

So, many water activities can be done here like swimming, boating, biking, taking walks and much more.

The island also has a museum, an animal farm, a gallery and a wildlife preserve. Anyway, this list is made for a different reason and not the island in general but it is never bad to know what else you can do while at a place.

You might be wondering where you can go to have a good time on the island and there are places obviously as you will see from this list.

We are focusing strictly on bars today. These are the 12 best block island bars.

 

12 Best Block Island Bars

1. Yellow Kittens tavern

This s a beautiful little spot located on Corn Neck Road, New Shoreham in Block Island. It is located near the shore and you get a very beautiful beach view while there.

It is the oldest night club on the island. The staff is very welcoming and they have mazing food there as well with burgers, nachos, chicken fingers and even salads.

They have a kid’s menu too for someone who wants to go with kids. I know you are looking for a bar but great food is always a plus no matter what.

They have a pool table and darts too for those who love bar games or would like to try one. I almost forgot about the ping pong table.

They have one too which is absolutely amazing. Then of course the amazing drinks. Their drinks menu has cocktails, wines, beers, spirits and also nonalcoholic drinks.

I didn’t forget about the music obviously. It is very modern and they have a DJ who plays great music.

They have live music shows too sometimes. So, this is the best low-key bar you can go to on Block Island.

 

2. Mahogany Shoals

Mahogany Shoals is a great place located at 133 ocean Ave, New Shoreham at Payne’s dock in Block Island. It is a beautiful simple spot with a relaxing vibe.

It is a great place to go to late at night to feel the breeze in a cozy atmosphere and get good drinks and relax with friends or family.

They have a food menu and they serve numerous dishes like seafood. Their food is not exceptional but it is good.

They have a good drinks menu and they serve anything from beer to vodka and so much more. They have a sitting are at the deck where you can sit and look at the marina and all the activities on the water.

The bar also has live music every night in the summer which is very refreshing. I must tell you though that the place does not accept ATMs.

It is exclusively cash at the bar. It is a good bar with good food, great music and amazing drinks. The staff is kind too and very attentive and receptive to customers.

 

3. Captain Nick’s Rock and Roll bar

It is really a rock and roll bar because you do rock and roll while there. Anyway, Captain Nicks rock and rollbar is located at 34 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham in Block Island.

If you prefer a night of loud music and dancing to one of listening to relaxing calm music while sitting and sipping on your drink, this is your place.

This is one of the most popular bars on the island. You must be wondering why it is not my number one but I also cater to those who prefer low sounds to loud music.

It is of course more popular with younger people and it always has a full crowd compared to other places on the island.

They are strict and tight on security so only people who are 21 are allowed indoors. They have two live stages though. One inside and the other outside.

So, if you forget your ID or are not yet 21, you can still catch a show on the outside stage if lucky. They have amazing drinks too otherwise why would the place be popular?

They also take cash only so be prepared. So, if you want to go out for a night of drinking and dancing, Captain nick’s is the best on the island.

 

4. Club Soda

This one is located at 35 Connecticut Ave, New Shoreham in Block Island. It is located in the middle of a residential area and is often frequented by the locals of the area.

However, when you discover this one, you will be amazed. The first thing that appeals to me is their giant chess board.

For all my people that love games while having a good time drinking, this is the best option. They obviously have great drinks and amazing music which is simple and not very loud so you can just hangout at the bar for as long as you want.

Back to the games, they have the life-sized chess board which is fun to play on. They have a pool table, foosball, connect four, janga and for all the nerds, they have video games too.

They also have fun activities depending on the day you go, you might get trivia, comedy, live music, karaoke, talent shows and musical bingo. It is an all-round place that is fun for adults of any age group because you cannot fail to have a good time there.

Club Soda is therefore one of the best bars on block island.

 

5. Spring House Hotel

The spring house hotel is a beautiful little hotel on Block Island. It is the oldest hotel on the island. Its address is 52 Spring St, Block Island.

This place has two bars on its property. One is outside on their veranda while the other is indoors. Here you are spoilt for choice because you can go wherever works for you.

Of course, the bar that is outdoors allows you to have a stunning ocean view while enjoying your drink which is so calming and peaceful.

They have live music at this bar and also performances every night during the summer including pianist shows or a full band experience.

There is also a bar indoors which has great drinks and good calming music for people who prefer being indoors.

The bar has a large seating area too so it can accommodate a reasonably large group of people. There is also the option of sitting outside on the grass in front of the hotel.

There are seats provided and the staff waits on people sitting there too. So, Spring House Hotel is also a great place with two good bars.

 

6. Ballard’s Beach Resort

Ballard’s beach resort is a great location to go for a relaxing day. it is located at 42 Water St, Block Island. It has several tiki bars which start serving drinks at 10am.

This one right here is my favourite because when you are on holiday, day drinking does not seem like such a bad idea.

They serve a variety of drinks including exotic cocktails sometimes with many variations of the same drink like the Ballard’s bloody bar’s variation of the Bloody Mary drink where they have the Classic Mary, the Boom Boom Mary and the Skinny Vodka Mary.

They serve elegant wines and beers too. the vibe there is mostly a party always on the move vibe. The resort also has live music performances every day during the summer.

They have an entertainment calendar available online where you can find out what particular performers are performing and when to plan your time there better.

Here, you can enjoy your drinks and also have simple access to other stuff at the resort like great restaurants, the hotel and the beach. You must also know that the resort went cashless.

This is definitely the worthiest Block Island bar location.

 

7. Poor Peoples Pub

I do not know what they meant by Poor Peoples Pub. Probably something along the lines of affordable for everyone or did they mean something else?

We don’t know but I love the place. This bar is not showy and out there like some others on the island. It is located at 33 ocean Ave, Block Island.

They have both an indoors and an outdoors sitting area. So, you can sit where you like depending on what you prefer. They have spectacular food and serve great drinks. It is a simple uncomplicated bar that you can go just to hangout and have conversations with friends and/or family.

On Sunday, they host a popular “Rehab Brunch” where you can buy 5-dollar mimosas. On Friday and Saturday, they host dance parties.

You can also just sit by the bar and watch the game (whatever game is on, I’m not good with sports) on their flat screen TVs (they have a couple).

It is a good lowkey bar that is not so out there but is a great place and I am sure that you will have a good time there.

 

8. Beach bar

This is located at Block Island Beach House, 32 Dodge Street, New Shoreham. This place like most of the others offers both food and drinks.

They have a great menu for adult and children. It is a more family friendly place especially when one us taking little kids as well. It is less rowdy and crowded compared to other locations.

They have everything for everyone. Great cocktails for adults and good simple foods for the kids like their amazing tacos.

You also get an amazing view of the beach while here so you do not miss out on the beauty of the island by being indoors.

The thing that draws me to this one is that even parents can have a good time without worrying about how and where they left their children.

It closes early though probably because they entertain children too. anyway, if you are looking for a simple fun place to be to enjoy your drinking even with children around, this is definitely the place to go. The staff is nice and welcoming too.

 

9. Old Island Pub

This pub is located at 85 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham in Block Island. It is a relatively small place that looks like someone’s house and its appearance does add to its appeal.

They have a small food menu and a large bottled beer list. They have liquor and wines too. it is not well known because it is Block island’s most recent pub and is still known by a few people. The advantages of this is that there is a lesser crowd and the service is amazing.

The place has weekly kitchen specials on the menu. They also have Taco Tuesday and Sunday brunch.

Like most of the other bars here, the Old Island pub also hosts live music shows frequently. They are open all year from noon to 1 in the morning.

I would definitely frequent this pub for its food because it is great and to have the occasional drink every now and then. I guarantee you will love this place.

 

10. Block island oyster bar and grill

This bar is located at 251 Spring St, new Shoreham, block island. They offer food and drinks and music.

Their food is great semi fancy food including lobster, tuna, land chops and so much more. Going to a bar with great food too is such a steal if you ask me.

You do not have to go hoping across town at 2 am looking for a great food place because it is right there.

A 2 in 1 deal. Anyway, this bar is also not as popular but it is a good bar. It has great drink options too including liquor, beer and wine.

Most people talk about it because of the food though and the amazing severs who are both kind and attentive.

They also have an indoor sitting area and an outdoor one. it is a beautiful and cozy place to go for a quiet evening dining with your loved one(s). I 100% recommend this beautiful spot.

 

11. The Harbor Grill & Orchid Lounge (Waterfront, Sea Food, Steak & Bar)

It is located at 41 Water St, New Shoreham in Block Island. This is also more of a restaurant that a bar but we do appreciate that here too. Like I said, great food is a bonus to a bar.

They are usually open from 8 am to 9 pm except for Tuesday to Friday where they open at 11 am. The view is amazing from here.

You get to eat good food, have a drink or two and enjoy the beautiful ocean view. They serve cocktails, beer and liquor.

There is outdoor seating available too. the staff is amazing which adds to the appeal of the place. They are so kind and helpful.

Some people say they have the best food on Block Island. For reviews like that, it is worth a try.

 

12. The National Tap & Grille

This great restaurant is located at 36 Water St, New Shoreham in Block Island. It is a lively but also chill area that is great for a quiet evening.

They have good food which absolutely everyone should try when they go to the island. And they do serve cocktails, wine and beer at the bar.

They have a good view too. they have an outdoor seating area so you definitely have options. The cocktails are really good and I urge you to try this place.

These are the 12 best Block Island bars. There are so many other cozy spots too that I have not mentioned but you can go beyond this list and try out many more.

The island is beautiful with a great ocean view that can be caught from almost anywhere on the island.

So, if you are visiting Block Island, or if you are a new resident looking to explore, this list is for you. There is so much to enjoy. Some bars have great games and a cozy scene.

Some have loud music and active DJs and you can have a night of dancing.

Other places have great live music and are generally quitter. Then others have trivia, bingo and karaoke. So, you need to choose according to what you are interested in the most.

Or, you can go bar hoping because it is a small island and you can go from place to place if you want to see more in a short time.

You need to try out all the other activities too that the island has to offer to make your trip a fulfilling one.